The Scottish Farmer
The National Sheep Association this week welcomed the concept of the new laws, but urged Defra minister George Eustice and his colleagues to progress the idea with caution, to ensure all its implications are fully understood.
NSA chief executive Phil Stocker said: “NSA fully recognises the importance of the ethnic market to sheep farmers and we agree that, although not ideal, it is unrealistic to think we could ban non-stun slaughter.
“Around 85% of halal slaughtering is already pre-stunned and there is very little ‘leakage’ of non-stun product into mainstream markets, but given the level of confusion among consumers, it is right that labelling of non-stun meat is considered.
“However, it should be remembered that there are a number of farm assurance schemes and labels that already prohibit the use of their logos on non-stunned products, including Red Tractor Assurance, Soil Association Organic and Freedom Foods, and any development of non-stun information should be done in partnership with these organisations to avoid overcomplicating labels,” he suggested.
“Carcase balance for non-stunned products will be the challenge and the wider outstanding issue of effective labelling in wholesale and catering markets needs to be tackled at the same time to protect the integrity of our sheep farmers and their high quality products.”
But the key ‘unintended consequence’ of raising this issue amongst Muslim consumers might be that it alerts them to the current use of pre-stunning in the majority of halal production – which could actually provoke an increase in demand for non-stun products from this key lamb market.
“We would suggest to the government that its help and support in being able to demonstrate that electric stunning is simply that – recoverable stunning (not death) that renders an animal unconscious prior to slaughter,” added Mr Stocker.
“If this could be demonstrated and proven to the Muslim community it would go a long way to fulfilling their religious beliefs and reducing reliance on non-stun methods.”